A recent study found that face shields alone are not highly successful in avoiding COVID-19 contamination without masks. Researchers examined what happens to the airflow around these plastic screens when anyone nearby sneezes.

Face shields are usually synthetic shields sometimes worn by physicians treating COVID-19 patients as part of their protective equipment. The report, reported in the Physics of Fluids journal, observed that the number of people using face shields as a replacement for face masks has been growing in bars, beauty salons, and shops. Few choirs have already begun to work with them as well.

Numerous online videos illustrate how home-made models can be fashioned from clear binder covers, hollow packets of fizzy drinks, or left-over disposable packaging. 

Major corporations such as Apple, Babcock, Ford, and Nike have used their manufacturing lines to create face shields, while Oakley's athletic brand has built face shields to wear on their helmets for NFL athletes.

Singapore and certain US states advised people who appear in court, give lectures or act in public to wear face shields. Although several states in Australia suggest face shields should be used rather than face masks in public.

Ambev Pioneers in Diverting from its Core Business to Produce Face Shield Masks to be Donated to Hospitals Amidst the Coronavirus (COVID -19) Pandemic
(Photo: Alexandre Schneider/Getty Images)
OSASCO, BRAZIL - APRIL 30: A worker assembles face shield masks on April 29, 2020, in Osasco, Brazil. Ambev partnered with Bizsys to produce face shield masks with the same material as the PET bottle of Guarana Antarctica (one of Ambev's most famous soft drinks in Brazil) already cut into sheets. The face shield masks will be donated to health professionals in public and private hospitals fighting against the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic. Ambev was born in 1999 from the merger between the centenarians 'Cervejaria Brahma' and 'Companhia Antarctica.' Interbrew from Belgium and Ambev merged to create InBev. Belgium-Brazilian InBev acquired Anheuser-Busch from the United States, creating the world's biggest brewer.

Why a face shield alone may not protect you from coronavirus

The physicists, including some from the University of Fukuoka in Japan, said that sneezes create a fluid phenomenon known as vortex rings. These can trap microscopic particles and travel through the mask's membrane.

"A vortex ring is a donut-shaped vortex generated by an instantaneous ejection of fluid from a circular orifice. His resembles bubble rings made by dolphins," explained study co-author Fujio Akagi from Fukuoka University.

In the analysis, the researchers tested what occurs when an infectious individual standing one meter in front of them is subjected to a sneeze by a face shield wearer.

"The vortex rings generated by the sneeze capture the microscopic droplets within the sneeze and transports them to the top and bottom edges of the face shield," Akagi said.

They said that the microscopic droplets transported by the vortex rings would get within the shield through its top and bottom sides.

"It was also confirmed that some particles - in this simulation, 4.4 percent of the released droplets - penetrated inside of the face shield and entered the area of the nose," the scientists wrote in the report.

The researchers conclude that face shields alone are not extremely successful in avoiding contamination with COVID-19. However, after a deeper understanding of the face shield's limitations, they aim to strengthen safety by decreasing the shield's flow.

How often should we wear face shields, then?

Other studies also sought to determine how the wearer should be shielded from other individuals around them.

The Israel Institute for Biological Science used water-sensitive paper stuck across a mannequin's face wearing a plastic face shield in a new, though still undisclosed, report. It was as successful as a face mask with bigger droplets sprayed straight onto the wearer's face from a cough or sneezed 60cm (2ft) out. The shield seems to be up to 10 times more effective than the mask against fine aerosols.

Visors provide a range of benefits over masks, such as eye defense and maybe an entrance point for certain infections into the body. They will also help reduce the possibility of scratching their face and inoculating themselves with some infection on their hands that they have picked up. They are often commonly known to be more relaxed as the wearer breathes, and fog glasses fewer.

Face covers, though, tend to be only genuinely successful in suitable circumstances: when someone coughs directly on the plastic paper. The wearer may be running about near their clients in certain daily circumstances, such as hair salons, as they cut hair.

ALSO READ: Volunteer for Pfizer's Experimental COVID-19 Vaccine Shares Side Effects from Trial


Check out more news and information on COVID-19 on Science Times.